.webp)
For families performing Umrah, travelling from Makkah to Madinah can look simple until children, elderly pilgrims, a stroller and several suitcases are added to the journey. At that point, choosing between a private taxi and the Haramain Train becomes about much more than travel time alone.
The Haramain Train is attractive for station-to-station speed, especially for one or two passengers travelling light. A family, however, still needs to reach the station in Makkah, move everyone and their luggage through the station, board on time, and arrange another transfer after arriving in Madinah. A private vehicle takes longer on the road, but the journey can begin at the hotel door and finish at the next hotel.
That difference matters more as the group becomes larger. With a private transfer, the family pays for the vehicle, while train travel is normally priced per passenger. For groups of four, six or seven people, the cost per person of a private vehicle can drop sharply once the fare is shared across the family.
For one or two passengers travelling light, the Haramain Train can be difficult to beat for speed and price.
For larger families, especially those travelling with children, elderly pilgrims or several bags, a private vehicle can become much more competitive because the fare covers the vehicle rather than individual passenger tickets.
Answer note: Private-transfer prices below come from the Umrah Transportations 2026 route rate list. Train totals are worked examples, not live quotes, because rail fares can change by date, class and availability.
Private Taxi vs Haramain Train: Quick Comparison
| Factor | Private Taxi | Haramain Train |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing | Example route fares: Sedan SAR 500 / Staria SAR 600 / Hiace SAR 750 / GMC XL SAR 1,150 | Makkah–Madinah Economy commonly listed around SAR 145–170 per passenger; worked examples below use SAR 150 |
| Journey | Hotel-to-hotel | Station-to-station |
| Extra transfers | Usually none | Required at both ends |
| Children | Fewer journey changes | Station transfers + fixed departure |
| Elderly passengers | Direct pickup reduces movement | Accessibility assistance available |
| Luggage | Depends on vehicle capacity | Current train baggage rules apply |
| Speed | Longer road journey | Faster station-to-station |
What Actually Changes When a Family Travels from Makkah to Madinah?
Haramain Train Journey
Private Transfer Journey
Taxi vs Train Cost by Family Size
Public 2026 fare guides commonly place Makkah–Madinah Haramain Economy tickets around SAR 145–170 per passenger. To keep the examples simple, the calculations below use SAR 150 per passenger. We also use an illustrative SAR 100 total allowance for local station transfers at both ends (SAR 50 + SAR 50). Your actual station transfers may be lower or higher.
Checked August 2026: check the live Haramain fare, timetable and availability on the official Saudi HHR booking website before travel.
For this comparison, the private-transfer figures below use the Umrah Transportations 2026 Makkah to Madinah rate list. The listed route fares are SAR 500 for a Sedan, SAR 600 for a Hyundai Staria, SAR 750 for a Hiace, SAR 1,150 for a Coaster, SAR 1,150 for a GMC XL, SAR 1,500 for a Bus, SAR 850 for a Lexus and SAR 650 for a Ford Taurus.
The important point for families is that a private-transfer fare is for the vehicle, not a separate ticket for every passenger. That means the effective cost per person falls as more family members share the same vehicle.
2 Passengers
Using the worked train example, two Economy tickets are 2 × SAR 150 = SAR 300. Add the illustrative SAR 100 for station transfers at both ends and the family journey becomes about SAR 400 total.
The published Makkah to Madinah Sedan fare is SAR 500 per vehicle, or about SAR 250 per person for two travellers. In this example, the train is around SAR 100 cheaper, so it can make strong financial sense for a couple travelling light.
The trade-off is convenience: the couple still needs to reach Makkah station, board on time and arrange onward transport from Madinah station.
Family of 4
Four Economy tickets at the worked rate are 4 × SAR 150 = SAR 600. Add the illustrative SAR 100 for the two station transfers and the total becomes about SAR 700.
A Hyundai Staria is listed at SAR 600 per vehicle, or SAR 150 per person for four passengers. In this worked example, the Staria is around SAR 100 cheaper than train tickets plus the transfer allowance.
For a family with children, a stroller or several bags, the direct hotel-to-hotel journey can also remove two extra vehicle changes. A Sedan is listed at SAR 500 for up to four passengers, but luggage volume should be considered before choosing it.
6 Passengers
Six Economy tickets at SAR 150 each come to 6 × SAR 150 = SAR 900. With the illustrative SAR 100 in station transfers, the worked train journey is about SAR 1,000 total.
The Hyundai Staria is listed at SAR 600 for the route: SAR 600 ÷ 6 = SAR 100 per person. That makes the private vehicle around SAR 400 lower than the worked train-plus-transfer example for six passengers.
A Hiace is listed at SAR 750 and may be more practical when the group has heavier luggage or wants more cabin space.
7 Passengers
Seven Economy tickets at SAR 150 each come to 7 × SAR 150 = SAR 1,050. Adding the illustrative SAR 100 for station transfers gives a worked total of about SAR 1,150.
A Hiace is listed at SAR 750, which is about SAR 107 per person for seven travellers. The GMC XL is listed at SAR 1,150, matching the worked train-plus-transfer total in this example but offering a different comfort and luggage setup.
The Hyundai Staria is listed at SAR 600 for up to seven passengers, but with seven people the luggage load becomes critical. A Hiace can be the safer choice when the family is carrying several large suitcases, while the GMC XL is the premium option.
Pricing note: Private-transfer fares are taken from the Umrah Transportations 2026 Makkah to Madinah rate list. Train figures in the worked examples are not a guaranteed live quote: they use SAR 150 per Economy ticket within the publicly listed 2026 range of roughly SAR 145–170, plus an illustrative SAR 100 total for local station transfers. Always check the current Haramain fare and your actual pickup/drop-off costs before booking.
Family Travel Is More Than Just Ticket Price
Young Children
Strollers, tired children and fixed departure times can make every additional transfer more noticeable.
Elderly & Mobility
The train provides accessibility assistance, while direct transport reduces the number of separate journey stages.
Luggage
For larger families, luggage capacity can matter just as much as passenger capacity when choosing a vehicle.
The Hidden Cost of the Train for Families
Station Transfers at Both Ends
The train fare is not always the full journey cost. A family staying at a Makkah hotel normally needs transport to the train station before departure. After arriving in Madinah, another ride may be required from the station to the hotel. For a couple this may still be manageable, but for a larger family the extra transfers add both cost and coordination.
Waiting, Boarding and Fixed Departure Time
Train travel works best when the family can comfortably follow a fixed schedule. That means leaving the hotel early enough for the station transfer, allowing time for entry and boarding, and keeping the whole group together. Families with young children or elderly pilgrims may value the simplicity of one direct pickup instead.
What Families With Elderly Pilgrims Should Consider
For an elderly pilgrim, the easiest option is not always the fastest one. The important question is how many separate stages the journey requires. Train travel can involve a hotel transfer, station movement, boarding, disembarking and another transfer at the destination. A private vehicle can reduce those stages to hotel pickup, the road journey and hotel drop-off.
This does not automatically make a taxi the better choice for every elderly traveller. Some families may still prefer the train because of its shorter station-to-station travel time. The practical decision should be based on the person's mobility, comfort with station movement and the amount of luggage the family is carrying.
What Happens When a Family Has 5–7 Suitcases?
Passenger capacity and luggage capacity are not the same thing. A vehicle may have enough seats for a family but still feel cramped once large suitcases, cabin bags and a stroller are added. This is why a six- or seven-person group should choose the vehicle according to both people and bags rather than seat count alone.
For lighter luggage, a Staria may be suitable for many family groups. When the group has several large suitcases, a Hiace can be the more practical choice because the extra space may matter more than a small difference in fare. The best approach is to provide the passenger count and approximate luggage count before booking so the vehicle can be matched to the actual trip.
When the Haramain Train Is Clearly the Better Choice
A private taxi is not automatically the best option. The Haramain Train can be the stronger choice for one or two travellers with light luggage, especially when station-to-station speed is the main priority. It can also work well for families that are comfortable with station transfers and prefer travelling on a fixed timetable.
The purpose of this comparison is not to make every traveller choose the same mode of transport. It is to compare the entire family journey rather than one ticket price or one road fare in isolation.
Quick Decision Guide
Choose the Haramain Train If...
- You are travelling alone or as a couple
- You have light luggage
- Station-to-station speed is the priority
- Station transfers are manageable
- A fixed timetable works for you
Choose a Private Taxi If...
- You are travelling with a family or group
- You have young children or a stroller
- An elderly passenger has limited mobility
- You are carrying several bags
- You prefer direct hotel pickup
Frequently Asked Questions
How much does a private Makkah to Madinah transfer cost for a family?
According to the Umrah Transportations 2026 rate list, Makkah to Madinah fares include SAR 500 for a Sedan, SAR 600 for a Hyundai Staria, SAR 750 for a Hiace and SAR 1,150 for a GMC XL. Larger vehicle options are also listed. Check the current fare and suitable vehicle before booking.
Is taxi or Haramain Train cheaper for a family?
It depends on group size and the live train fare. Using a worked Economy rate of SAR 150 per passenger plus an illustrative SAR 100 total for station transfers, the train is about SAR 400 for two passengers, SAR 700 for four, SAR 1,000 for six and SAR 1,150 for seven. Private Makkah to Madinah fares from the 2026 rate list include Sedan SAR 500, Staria SAR 600, Hiace SAR 750 and GMC XL SAR 1,150.
Is the Haramain Train suitable for elderly pilgrims?
Accessibility assistance is available, but passengers still need to travel between their hotel and the stations at both ends of the journey.
Which option is easier when travelling with children?
Both are possible. A private vehicle can reduce transfers, while the train offers a faster station-to-station journey.
Is a private taxi better when carrying several suitcases?
For larger luggage loads, vehicle capacity can make private transport more practical. The correct vehicle should be selected according to both passenger and luggage requirements.
Need a Private Transfer Between Makkah and Madinah?
View available vehicle options and choose a private transfer that suits your family size and luggage requirements.